How To Write A Mystery Short Story


Click the audio play button to hear the entire article!!!

Do you like stories with much mystery that keep you in your seat? If you like to tell stories and want to try writing a mystery short story, this is the place for you. Stop looking! This detailed guide shows you how to write an interesting short mystery story that draws people in. We’ll discuss everything, from creating interesting people to planning an interesting story. So, put on your detective hat and dive into the mystery writing world!

Writing a mystery short story is an exciting endeavor that allows you to create suspense, intrigue, and surprise your readers. This genre has a long-standing history, with legendary authors like Agatha Christie and Arthur Conan Doyle captivating audiences with their brilliant mysteries. Whether you’re a budding writer or an experienced author looking to venture into a new genre, this guide will provide valuable insights and techniques to help you craft a compelling mystery short story.

1. Understanding the Mystery Genre

Before you start writing, it’s important to understand what makes a mystery story a puzzle. Most mysteries are about a crime, usually a murder, that the main character, who is usually a detective or an amateur sleuth, has to solve. These stories are full of suspense, hidden hints, red herrings (false information), and plot twists you didn’t see coming. By learning the tropes and rules of the mystery genre, you can write a real, interesting story that hits home with readers. 

2. Choosing an Engaging Setting

The setting plays a vital role, akin to how to make a visual novel in creating the right atmosphere. and enhancing the overall reading experience. Whether it’s a small, picturesque town or a bustling city, the location should align with the tone and theme of your story. Consider the period, geography, and cultural aspects that can add depth and intrigue to your narrative. A well-developed setting can transport readers into the world of your story and make it more immersive.

3. Developing Memorable Characters

Any story is only as good as its people, and mysteries are no different. Your main character should be likable and have clear traits, strengths, and flaws. Whether the main character is a seasoned detective or an unlikely hero, the viewer should care about their journey and want them to succeed. Also, well-written secondary characters, like suspects and witnesses, can add more depth to your story. Focus on making personalities that readers will remember long after reading.

4. Crafting a Gripping Plot

A mystery short story must have a plot that flows well. Start by listing the most important parts of your story, like the crime, the investigation, and the end. The plot turns, surprises, and a sense of urgency will keep your readers interested and eager to find out the truth about your main character. Try out different plots, like the famous “whodunit” or the “inverted mystery,” to find the one that works best for your story.

5. Creating Suspense and Tension

A riddle story can’t exist without suspense. To keep people interested in your story, you need to build and keep up the drama throughout. Use techniques like hints, akin to the storytelling in how to become a comic book writer, to create suspense make people feel they must act quickly. The strategic placement of suspenseful moments and unexpected turns will leave readers wanting more and push them to figure out the puzzle before the final reveal.

6. Incorporating Clues and Red Herrings

In a mystery story, clues and false leads are the main parts. Clues are bits of information and hints that, when put together, help solve the riddle. On the other hand, red herrings are fake clues or details that lead the reader away from the truth. Find the right mix of hints and false leads to keep people guessing and interested in the investigation.

7. Building a Strong Beginning

The opening should captivate readers, much like the beginning of a fantasy novel. and set the stage for intrigue. Hook your audience with an attention-grabbing first line, introduce the main characters, and establish the initial conflict or crime. Consider starting with a compelling scene or a mysterious event to immediately engage readers’ curiosity and draw them into the story.

8. Developing the Middle Section

The middle section of your mystery short story is where the investigation intensifies and the plot thickens. Here, you’ll introduce suspects, reveal new clues, and delve deeper into the protagonist’s journey. Maintain a steady pace, balancing moments of suspense with character development and plot progression. Keep readers guessing by introducing twists and turns that challenge their assumptions.

9. Crafting a Satisfying Ending

The resolution of your mystery short story should provide a satisfying payoff for readers. Tie up loose ends, explain the motives behind the crime, and reveal the culprit’s identity in a logical and fulfilling way. Consider the emotional arcs of your characters and ensure their growth and development throughout the story. Avoid abrupt endings or dues ex machine solutions that may confuse readers.

10. Formatting and Polishing the Manuscript

Proper formatting is crucial, similar to the meticulousness in copy editing vs. proofreading for submission or self-publishing. Follow industry-standard guidelines for margins, font size, and line spacing. Proofread your manuscript meticulously to eliminate any grammatical, spelling, or typos. Use grammar checkers and style guides to ensure the manuscript is error-free and polished.

11. Self-Publishing vs. Traditional Publishing

Self-Publishing Vs. Traditional Publishing, as explored in the ultimate guide to how to publish a poetry book Once your mystery short story is ready to be published, you must choose between self-publishing and traditional marketing. Self-publishing lets you keep artistic control and get a bigger share of the royalties, but you must do the publishing yourself. In traditional publishing, you send your manuscript to literary agents or publishing houses, which may help you get your book out to a bigger audience and with marketing. Carefully look into both paths to see which fits your goals and means best.

12. Collaborating with Alpha Book Writers

Alpha Book Writers is a trusted partner for authors looking to enhance their writing and publishing journey. Whether you need professional editing, book cover design, or formatting services, amazon book publisher services offers a range of solutions tailored to your specific needs. Collaborate with industry experts who share your passion for storytelling and ensure your mystery short story reaches its full potential.

13. Leveraging Book Publishing Services

Navigating the publishing process can be overwhelming, but you can streamline the journey with the assistance of book publishing services. From manuscript evaluation to typesetting and distribution, these services comprehensively support authors. Explore options like Alpha Book Writers’ publishing services, where experienced professionals guide you through each step, ensuring a seamless and successful publishing experience.

14. Boosting Sales with Effective Book Promotion

Employ effective book promotion strategies to maximize sales of your mystery short story. Leverage social media advertising to target specific audiences and generate buzz around your book. Engage in collaborations with other authors for cross-promotion. Offer limited-time discounts or promotions to incentivize readers to purchase your book. Leverage the power of book reviews and testimonials to build credibility and attract new readers.


Putting together a short mystery story can be exciting and fun. You can write a mystery that keeps readers guessing until the end if you know the genre, build interesting characters, make an interesting plot, and use good writing techniques. Before you think about sharing your story, read, edit, and polish it. With hard work, practice, and a little imagination, you can write a short mystery story that grabs readers’ attention and makes them want to read more.

Struggling To Write And Publish Your Book Easily?
Why not hire a professional writer and publisher? Feel free to reach us."

Get Started +18772093121 Live Chat


All company logos and trademarks appearing on our website are the property of their respective owners. We are not affiliated, associated, endorsed by, or in any way officially connected with these companies or their trademarks. The use of these logos and trademarks does not imply any endorsement, affiliation, or relationship between us and the respective companies. We solely use these logos and trademarks for identification purposes only. All information and content provided on our website is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as professional advice. We do not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of any information provided on our website. We are not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for the results obtained from the use of this information. Any reliance you place on such information is strictly at your own risk.